
Taste is a process, not a photograph
Classical methods give an integral score, but perception unfolds over time: attack, plateau, aftertaste. Temporal (dynamic) methods measure exactly this dynamics.
Time-Intensity (TI) — the assessor continuously moves the intensity slider of a single attribute from the first taste to the aftertaste. Parameters are extracted from the curve: Imax (maximum), Tmax (time to maximum), AUC (area under the curve), duration, rising and falling angles. The parameters are compared by ANOVA.
TI curves: menthol cooling intensity in two chewing gums
TDS: temporal dominance of sensations
TDS (Temporal Dominance of Sensations) — the assessor sees a list of attributes and at each moment marks the dominant one (the most noticeable — not necessarily the most intense). The time of each tasting is standardised to 0–100 %; dominance curves show the share of the panel for which the attribute dominates at a given moment.
The curves are read through two lines:
- the chance level line = 1/k, where k is the number of attributes: below it, dominance is indistinguishable from random picking;
- the significance line — the smallest share significantly exceeding chance (exact binomial test, α = 0.05); it depends on the data volume (assessors × replicates).
Key TDS parameters: dominance rate (the share of the panel for which the attribute dominates), time to first dominance, duration of dominance. Product comparison — difference curves with significance limits.
Time standardisation and statistical testing
Assessors taste at different tempos, so the "raw" curves are not averaged directly: the time of each run is normalised from the start of evaluation (x₀) to swallowing (x₁) — separately for the "in-mouth" phase and the "aftertaste" phase. After normalisation all curves share a common 0–100 % scale, and the panel shares at each point are binomial proportions for which the significance line is computed exactly (as in the widget above).
For the conclusion "products differ in their curves" the significance line alone is not enough — it tests individual points. The accepted approach is randomization tests (Meyners & Pineau, 2010): a curve-difference statistic (e.g. the area of the difference curve) is compared with the distribution of the same statistic under thousands of random permutations of the product labels. For TCATA data the same difference curves, confidence bands and "contrail" trajectories with uncertainty ellipses are used (Castura et al., 2016 — open access).
Case: optimising the flavour "breakdown" of milk chocolate
A panel compared three recipes (50 %, 70 %, 85 % cocoa) by TDS:
- 50 % cocoa: the "milky" dominance holds for the first 40 % of the time, then a smooth transition to "caramel" — a harmonious profile;
- 70 % cocoa: "cocoa" disappears too quickly, leaving an "empty" tail — consumer complaints of "lack of character";
- 85 % cocoa: early dominance of "cocoa", late dominance of "roast"; bitterness stays significantly above the significance line for the whole second half-period.
The fix for the 70 % recipe: adding milk fat prolonged the "cocoa" dominance and removed the dip. Business effect — a 15 % growth in repeat purchases after the relaunch (a teaching case based on industry practice).
TCATA and other variants
- TCATA (Temporal Check-All-That-Apply) — at each moment several applicable attributes can be ticked; analysis by citation curves and "fading" (sequential un-ticking).
- MTS (multiple TDS) — parallel TDS runs by modality (taste/aroma/texture).
- Time standardisation to 0–100 % is mandatory: assessors chew at different speeds, and without normalisation the curves cannot be combined.
Further reading
- Di Monaco R., Su C., Masi P., Cavella S. Temporal Dominance of Sensations: A Review. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 2014 — the principal TDS review: methodology, statistics, criticism. review
- Schlich P. Temporal Dominance of Sensations (TDS): A New Deal for Temporal Sensory Analysis. Current Opinion in Food Science, 2017 — a look at the method's current state from one of its creators. review
- Castura J. C., Antúnez L., Giménez A., Ares G. Temporal Check-All-That-Apply (TCATA): A Novel Dynamic Method for Characterizing Products. Food Quality and Preference, 2016 — the original TCATA publication, open access. article · OA
- Ares G. et al. Comparison of TCATA and TDS for Dynamic Sensory Characterization of Food Products. Food Research International, 2015 — a head-to-head comparison of the two temporal methods on the same products. article
Test yourself
Three questions on temporal methods
1. How does TDS differ from TI?
TI: one attribute, continuous intensity. TDS: many attributes, discrete choice of the dominant one. The methods answer different questions.
2. In a TDS with 6 attributes, the chance level line equals…
Chance level = 1/k = 1/6 ≈ 16.7 %. Significantly above it — only dominance above the significance line (binomial test).
3. Why is time standardised to 0–100 % in TDS?
Tasting duration differs severalfold between people; time normalisation is a condition for curve comparability.
Bringing the statistics together
Module 09 — all the statistical methods of sensory science in one place: from the binomial distribution to PCA.